A Saint and Sardines

A Saint and Sardines

By Br Bede Mullens, O.P. | St Thomas Aquinas was an intellectual giant with a wide heart and a wide girth. What can we learn from his life and teaching on his feast day?

“You have written well of me, Thomas: what gift would you have?”

The figure of the Lord addressed St Thomas Aquinas from the crucifix. This was one of very few mystical experiences in Thomas’ life, though he was a man who made constant recourse to prayer.

Non nisi te, Domine – Nothing but thee, O Lord,” he answered.

When this occurred, Thomas was at the height of his powers as a teacher and thinker. His fame had spread through the universities. His holiness too was already well recognised. This combination of qualities had surely inspired Pope Urban IV’s commission, that Thomas should compose the liturgical office for the newly instituted feast of Corpus Christi. It was while praying over his teaching on the Holy Eucharist that Thomas experienced the vision we just recounted.

Some years later, very shortly before his death, Thomas fell ill at the home of his niece. He had been travelling to take part in the Council of Lyons, which it was hoped would achieve reconciliation with the Greek Orthodox churches. But his powers had been noticeably diminished for some time. While he lay ailing on his sickbed, it was asked him one day, “What would you like to have, Thomas?” And the saint’s reply came, “Well, I wouldn’t mind some herring.”

Now, one couldn’t come by herring in 13th century Maenza; sardines were the stock fish of that region. So someone was sent to fetch some sardines as a near-substitute. When he arrived at the fish stall, however, and the fishmonger lifted the lid off his sardines he found – not sardines, but herring. And Thomas was most satisfied.

This, remarkably, is one of only a very small handful of miracles in St Thomas’ life which are genuinely attested. Surely, this is beneath the dignity of a saint? How could a man, who wanted nothing but Christ in his prime, have had a craving for kippers at his low ebb?

It is one of the jolliest things about the theology of St Thomas, that it leaves us room for liking herring (and kippers and sardines and any other fish that takes your fancy) just as much as for loving God. The reason why is simple: there can be no competition between God and his creation. On the contrary, it is God who created it, God who makes the gift of creation to us. Without God, there would be no herring. When we enjoy herring, we are receiving a gift from God. Does not St Paul tell us that all food is acceptable, just so long as we give thanks for it?

“You open wide your hand, and satisfy the hunger of every living thing”: so runs the Dominican grace before meals. What’s equally important about Thomas’ teaching, is that it tells us not to stop at physical hunger. We humans should be hungry for the Giver also – so hungry that we can say with Thomas, “I want nothing but you, Lord”. For God will give us even that. He will give us Himself, and He will even give us Himself in the form of food.

Next time you receive Holy Communion, give some thought to St Thomas, and give thanks to God for all His good gifts.

Image: St Thomas Reading (Wikimedia Commons)



Br Bede is a student brother in solemn vows. He was born in Enfield and grew up in Essex, before reading Literae Humaniores at St Hugh’s College in the University of Oxford. It was in Oxford that he first met the Dominicans, and he joined the Order in 2017 after completing his degree. The writings of Pope Benedict XVI/Joseph Ratzinger greatly influenced his development in the Faith. He retains a wide interest in literature; among religious authors, he particularly admires St Augustine and St John Henry Newman.

Comments (3)

  • A Website Visitor

    Thank you for a refreshing thought on St Thomas. Such a pity so many don’t see the real person.

  • A Website Visitor

    Thank you for this reflection on St. Thomas Aquinas. I will present this idea of creation not being at odds with God to my First Communion class this Sunday. I think they’ll appreciate the miracle about the herring and hopefully reflect on their hunger for God as they prepare to receive the Eucharist this April.

  • A Website Visitor

    I’d really appreciate hearing the entire Dominican grace before meals. Among other ministries, I am a chaplain for a senior center, and like to use diverse table prayers so all may feel as at home as possible…we have many different faiths and some agnostics and atheists, but words of thankfulness seem to be accepted by all. Thank you. Blessings!

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.